Wow, another cheese! Thanks bbracken667. I agree with you, I love sharp cheddar. My wife brought me back some 3 or 4 year old cheddar from the Amana Colonies in Iowa. It was great. About 15 years ago I picked up some Atomic Cheddar there. It was so sharp you could cut yourself with it. I thought it was great, but not likely everyone would.
I also hope to be able to age a cheddar that long. For the moment, just happy what I have made at least seems like cheese.