Stinky,
Assuming you used a viable culture in the correct amount the pH should be lower. The other variables are temperature and the availability of lactose. You should be keeping the curd around 93-95F and it shouldn't be so dry as to have ALL the whey drained. Oh, have you calibrated your pH meter lately?
I guess if it were my cheese I'd keep it unsalted and warm as above, check the pH meter (be sure the electrodes aren't clogged with dried cheese goo) and monitor any pH change over the next hour. If all this fails and the curds have a little bit of tang then I'd probably salt it and go on with the make.
Yesterday I made some Caerphilly (details posted) and checked the whey pH after the curds were cut. I checked again after awhile to get a fix on the rate of drop and found no change. The probe felt a little greasy so I washed it with soap and warm water and retested to find a BIG drop. Then it was off to the races!
Kern