I am an American from Chicago living in the Netherlands. Can't find cheddar here, so I bring back a brick of Cabot (or similar brand) every trip back to USA. I ultimately decided to attempt to make my own cheddar at home (HA. Brilliant idea....)
So, the research began. Watched maybe a dozen or more YouTube videos (including Mad Millie one), read a dozen sites on it, and figured I was well researched enough to make the attempt. (Should have known better.... my first batch of mead all those years ago was a disaster as well... barely drinkable 11 years later). Bought a "Mad Millie" Top up Kit, a cheese mold, cheesecloth etc, and began following the Mad Millie method. Started with 6 liters of biological (organic) milk, with a pint of heavy cream as a kicker. Added the calcium chloride, warmed it, added the dissolved rennin and the mesophilic culture. However, at curd cutting time, things didn't seem to be set as well as it should. I put the pot in a sink of hot water to try to warm it enough, which seemed to help some, but I still didn't think it was right. Wrong milk? Old rennin? bad culture? I still don't know, which makes me reluctant to try again. I dumped off the whey, added salt, put it in the mold, and then my press (adapted my fruit press with a bathroom scale beneath it). It was wet and runny, even after using the recommended amounts of pressure. I ultimately just cranked it down to like 100 lbs for 2 days. Then took it out, and it didn't cohere. Turned into a crumbly mess on the counter. I wrapped it in cheesecloth and have had it hanging in the kitchen for about a week or more now. Has a kind of sticky, slippery residue on cheesecloth now, but it's pretty dry.
Am really ready to throw it out, but don't want to waste time, effort and $ on another batch until I know what happened here. Any suggestions or ideas are welcomed.