Hi Mary
In my link above there are some recommendations and links to recipes that use standard off the shelf ingredients, I like Queso Fresco. The first non-normal ingredient you will need is rennet. I found some
Malaka brand in coincidentally the refrigerated cheese section of US Whole Food Market grocery chain, but I had to phone 2 stores before I found any in stock.
Otherwise you'll need
to order some, in which case you could order other stuff as well. Once you get some rennet then I'd go to American Neufchatel (light cream cheese) and then as you have goat's milk, Chevre or to a hard pressed cheese but then you'll need a mold.
Assuming you'll be using your own goat's milk, for fresh cheeses you'll need to think strongly about pasteurization first.
Hope other milk goat owners can chime in here.
Have fun!