Are you turning this cheese every day? Some moisture does expel during the intial drying phase, which is why it needs to be air dried for a bit before it is waxed or otherwise coated.
Drying times are variable because temperatures, humidity levels, barometric pressure, what the cow is eating at a given time, point in her lactation, etc., can affect the cheese. Throw in variables in the make, slight though they may be, and you can see why drying times are usually stated as 3-5 days, for instance.
Just keep turning it until it is dry to the touch.