John,
pH strips are just not accurate enough for serious cheese making. But looking at you photos, it looks over acidified and beyond the stretch range. Once the pH has dropped too much, there is nothing you can do about it.
If your pH was 5.5 when you put it in the frig, that was too low and it continued to acidify, though more slowly, overnight.
So, without a pH meter what I would do on day 2 is use your test strips until you get to 5.5-5.6. Be sure you are NOT any lower than that. Go ahead and check a small piece now and see if it will stretch. Then you will need to do "stretch tests" every half hour or so until you actually get to a workable pH. Just keep in mind that after it starts stretching you are at the TOP of the working pH range so let it go another half hour and then stretch.