I'll get the list started!
I get all my Cheese making supplies from What Ale's Ya? It's located on Bell rd. between 67th and 61st ave. right by a self storage place.
What Ale's Ya? is a wine and beer brewing supply shop that has just recently started stocking cheese making supplies. All of their products are Mad Millie brand, and although they used to have a very small stock, I just visited today and they have everything that is on the Mad Millie website (sadly the website is incomplete, but it seems to have every product but no real descriptions).
What Ale's Ya? has all kinds of cultures, molds, lipase, rennet, calcium chloride, cheese presses, cheese mold of all sizes, wax, plastic, cheese cloth, and various wrappings, citric acid, salts, herbs, etc, etc.
Be sure to visit them if you are in the area, and if you shop there, feel free to leave a reply here!