I have attempted to keep some kind of record of the different cheeses I tried to make. This was started in the form of a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet way back when. It gives me a rough upfront view of what I have tried and failed at or actually succeeded at.
The sheet isn't perfect but it does consolidate some of the highlights for each make. Data entry for the sheet is made easier by some note-taking at make time. My note-taking is not always spot on either.
I hadn't seen anyone else post a tracker such as this, but thought it might be inspirational for someone else.
Edited for an updated sheet: May 29, 2015