I brewed the same way when I started homebrewing, but as I got more involved in the hobby I started paying much more attention.
I have a computer program that calculates IBU and such from hops and gravity and color from malt.
As I got more serious, I got way more serious. I got so serious, that I went to brewing school, got a diploma in brewing and then lucked out at got a job at Sierra Nevada. At which point I essentially quit homebrewing.... LOL. Something about brewing 800bbl of beer a day all week just kills the drive to homebrew.
I'm still a complete newbie at cheesemaking, but I will get more serious and then I will learn more and make better cheese. I still need to make mistakes and learn from them.
Good news is that I just found a guy at work with goats and I now have access to fresh goat's milk! Woot.
I need to drop by the library and see if they have any cheesemaking books that I can borrow as my budget is such that it will be a bit before I can buy the books I want.
At any rate, this seems to be the most successful cheese that I have done so far..... Now to not screw up the rind maintenance.
MolBasser