CheeseForum.org ยป Forum

GENERAL CHEESE MAKING BOARDS (Specific Cheese Making in Boards above) => Problems - Questions - Problems - Questions? => Topic started by: UpMyKilt on October 09, 2016, 09:14:53 PM

Title: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 09, 2016, 09:14:53 PM
I am using a recipe from a kit.

It calls for 4 to 6 litres of milk using

1/8 teaspoon culture
1/4 tablet of rennet
1/4 teaspoon calcium chloride

If I go to 8 litres of milk (it's just easier than 6, and I'd like to do more than 4), is it safe or expected to simply double the amounts of the above ingredients?
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: john H on October 09, 2016, 09:24:46 PM
I would say yes but I always cross check the dosage on all packaging as there are different strengths of rennet and you don't want a bitter cheese. 

John
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 09, 2016, 09:32:45 PM
Thanks John. It was mostly the rennet I was concerned with. Unfortunately, the rennet package that I received has no dosage in English. I'll go do some googling :) The package says "novo" then underneath, "+QSO"

I can make out something about "50 litros" but that is all.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 09, 2016, 09:37:25 PM
This is where I received the kit - and the photo looks SIMILAR but not the same:

http://www.makecheese.ca/products/rennet-tablets (http://www.makecheese.ca/products/rennet-tablets)

But it seems the only rennet tablets on their site. Packaging from the tablet side looks identical to what they sent me, but my tablets are NOT scored into quarters, just halves.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: Andrew Marshallsay on October 09, 2016, 10:40:25 PM
I would agree with John that you should be able to double the 4 litre recipe for 8 litres.
Looking at the website that you gave the link for, the thing that struck me were the comments at the bottom about the contradictory information given on the packet. Given that, you may have to trust the dosage rate given in the instructions.
If you have used any of the tablets, you may have some idea of whether the quoted dosage rate is correct. Flocculation time should be around 10-15 minutes.
Your other option is to change to liquid rennet.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 09, 2016, 11:01:54 PM
Took a magnifying glass to what's on the package. It's Spanish. No English:

"Enzima coagulantes en tableta para cuajar 50 litros de leche como coadyuvante para elaborar quesos."

Means - "coagulating enzymes in tablet for 50 liters of milk curdle as an adjuvant to make cheese."

Do they mean it takes all ten tablets for 50 litres, or 1 tablet will do 50 litres?? LOL
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 09, 2016, 11:21:19 PM
Well, I'm going to go with half a tablet and see what happens :)

Yes.. I'm planning on purchasing liquid rennet soon. And some other things this kit did not come with - I'm enjoying the cheesemaking even if I started with a kit :)
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: Gregore on October 10, 2016, 04:27:55 AM
Hard to imagine 1 tablet does 50 liters / 13 gallons

if the recipe in the kit says 1/4 tablet for 4 to 6 liters then 1 tablet would do 16 to 24 liters and 10 tablets would do 160 to 240 liters.  So nothing really adds up correctly . ,

but the web site says 10 tablets is good for about 40 gallons of milk  and that is about 151 litters

So I think you will be fine with 1/2 tablet for 8 liters



Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 10, 2016, 05:52:11 AM
Thanks Gregore. I did use half a tablet. I just don't know enough yet - to know whether 1/4 would have worked for 8 litres - still learning here :)

The half tablet with 8 litres seemed to do the job as 1/4 with 4 litres.

I have lots to learn. Appreciate this group! :)

But now I'm wondering if I should have split up the resulting curd into two to drain. My 14 year old son thinks I should have waited until I got a second mould. LOL.. but at least he's interested and is finding the process of cheesemaking fascinating.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: Andrew Marshallsay on October 10, 2016, 09:00:25 AM
If your mould is big enough to take all the curd it shouldn't be a problem. Just stick it where it fits!
The only exceptions would be if you were making a mould ripened cheese, such as a Camembert, or a washed rind cheese. In those cases you do not want the cheese to be too thick.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: valley ranch on October 10, 2016, 08:20:45 PM
Kilt man, Show us if you will, a picture of your first product.

Richard
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 10, 2016, 11:03:59 PM
Quote from: valley ranch on October 10, 2016, 08:20:45 PM
Kilt man, Show us if you will, a picture of your first product.

Richard

I can't. The first product was far too crumbly to age in brine.

So I ate it all almost right away  ;D The whole pound of it!

I have some others in brine but they are in green mason jars.  I can't remember if I took photos; I'll check and see though.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 11, 2016, 12:28:22 AM
I checked. I did not take a photo of my first cheese attempt. Like I wrote, it turned out very crumbly. I'm still not sure why - although I did use a bit of weight when draining - but have not done that with subsequent attempts at this "feta style" cheese, and they have not turned out crumbly at all.

But I did take a photo of the cheese pot during my first attempt, after cutting the curd. :) Attached.

I believe I have a photo of my second attempt, which was using goat's milk.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 11, 2016, 12:37:46 AM
And this is chunks cut and salted, from an experiment of attempting a Bulgarian style brined white cheese - "Sirene" - made with both Probat 222 and real Bulgarian Yogurt.  I made the yogurt about two days before. I then added a couple of tablespoons of the yogurt to the milk (after warming it of course), then Probat 222 culture.

After I took the photo, I put the cheese on a draining mat and left it for a couple of days while pouring off the whey that had continued to expel.

I have not yet tried the cheese; it's presently in a whey brine.



Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 11, 2016, 12:56:35 AM
And the following images are from today. I started this yesterday - an 8-litre "batch" as I was getting tired of only getting a pound or so from all the hours of work! :)

I believe this is my 5th attempt, although I'd have to look at the labels on my bottles containing cheese that are aging. But to summarize:

1st Attempt - 4 litre Cow's Milk. Was confused as I had two sets of instructions from the same supplier which were different in some steps. Cheese turned out crumbly. But it tasted as good as any regular/economically priced feta at the grocery store.

2nd Attempt - 4 litre Goat's Milk. I felt more confident with the second batch and with some suggestions from Fritz here on this board. I have to give big Kudos to Fritz! I was very pleased with the texture. At first though - I was concerned as it seemed to taste bland.  The first batch, while crumbly, had a feta taste developing 24 hours after starting. This one.... I was concerned I might have mishandled the culture. However, after about a week, I was very pleased with the taste - it does taste subtly different than the cow's milk, but it's not unpleasant to me. I suppose I should sample more goat's milk cheeses to see if I "get" or understand what people mean when they say a "goaty taste."

3rd Attempt - 4 litre Cow's Milk. Turned out, at least for me, well. It's aging in brine right now.

4th Attempt - 4 litre Cow's Milk, but with the Bulgarian Yogurt variation.  Presently aging in whey brine.

5th Attempt - 8 litre Cow's Milk - started yesterday. Very pleased with taste and aroma so far.  Also, with this one, I really really really slowed down on the stirring. I was never really sure what "stir slowly" meant.  But I think I get it now :) The previous batches all seemed to have solid milk product in the whey after removing the curd; this most recent batch had much less.

Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: john H on October 11, 2016, 01:14:11 AM
Nice to see we can all learn together Kilt. I have been making cheese for a few years now and every time it gets a little easer. AC4Y keep at it kilt.

John
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 11, 2016, 02:28:41 AM
Thanks John! :)

I started this all about August 22nd of this year :)

I decided to try Feta because:

1. I really like Feta (although I love cheese in general).
2. It seemed like one of the easier things to start with for a beginner.
3. Not sure I have a suitable place for aging other types of cheese.
4. I have a Greek Lady friend who enjoys feta. A Lot.
5. I went with trying a Bulgarian style as I have a Bulgarian Lady friend who enjoys her "sirene."


Please don't tell my Irish Lady friend about the Greek or Bulgarian Lady Friends :p. Or vice versa.

But then there is my Italian Lady Friend who loves Barolo style wines and Asiago.

Yes, I've enjoyed the hobby of winemaking as well. At one time, had 10 5 gallon carboys along with a bunch of smaller ones, all going at once.

But those Lady Friends all drive me back to Irish Whiskey at times :P

Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: awakephd on October 11, 2016, 02:54:09 PM
Nice cheese porn. AC4U!
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: valley ranch on October 11, 2016, 03:20:35 PM
Looks good!
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 11, 2016, 04:07:01 PM
Thank you, Andy and Valley Ranch :)

If you happen to see anything that I am doing wrong or isn't quite right, please let me know! One does their best from instructions but it's not the same as watching/seeing it being done elsewhere, and then "copying" that.

But so far, everything is tasting really good! :)
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: valley ranch on October 11, 2016, 05:06:26 PM

Quote: Kilt guy, Please don't tell my Irish Lady friend about the Greek or Bulgarian Lady Friends :p. Or vice versa.

But then there is my Italian Lady Friend who loves Barolo style wines and Asiago.

Yes, I've enjoyed the hobby of winemaking as well. At one time, had 10 5 gallon carboys along with a bunch of smaller ones, all going at once.

But those Lady Friends all drive me back to Irish Whiskey at times :

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

No! I'm not going to comment or question! I give you my ornyalootion (blessing) on your cheese and wine making. Keep us up to date.
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: UpMyKilt on October 11, 2016, 07:18:28 PM
LOL Valley Ranch. Hopefully you know I'm just being "cheeky" or "saucy." :)

Okay... here we are putting the Goat Milk Feta, made back in the first week of September, to good use :) It's lunch time!

Feta slices on a tomato and roast beef sandwich. Yes - I made the bread as well :)

It is all... very good!

Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: valley ranch on October 11, 2016, 10:23:10 PM
That looks inviting, good for you!
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: Fritz on October 12, 2016, 03:18:31 AM
Awesome fresh looking lunch! Now THAT'S Real food kids .... gather around and see what it looks like ! Lol

Another cheese for you Ian, for keeping it real :)
Title: Re: Question - Ingredient Doubling
Post by: achik1990 on October 12, 2016, 03:22:14 AM
I use +QoS as well and I followed the recipe for making mozzarella (1/4 for 1 gallon of milk/4 litre instead of 1/4 for 12.5 litre, since 1 tablet : 50 litre)
the final product as distinctive bitter taste to it.
So yeah just follow the rennet instruction