The directions say to rehydrate the MA4001 directly in the milk for 5 minutes. I rehydrated in 1/4cup of warm water
I have to ask the obvious question: Why didn't you follow the directions?
I'm no expert, but it seems like rennet, lipase, and CACL2 are all passive enzyme or chemical additions, while the cultures are actually active, live populations that want nutrients coming out of stasis...and all you gave it was water.
Try adding the cultures directly to the at-temperature milk.
-Boofer-