Ah, 2 years isn't long.
I'm currently on my last quarter of a Romano style that is > 4 years old. The parmesan that will follow is currently32 months along; it will probably be 3 years old at least by the time I open it. I've also got about 1/3 of a Cantal in the cave that is right at 2.5 years old, and I've got a long-aging Gouda in the cave that is just shy of 2 years old. With the Gouda I'm aiming for at least 3 years before I open it.
The key to long aging is to have a rotation of cheeses that you make, something like this:
- Short-aging cheese (3 wks - 3 months)
- Medium-aging cheese (3 months-1 year)
- Short aging cheese
- Medium-aging cheese
- Short aging cheese
- Long aging cheese (>1 year)
- Go back to #1 and repeat
The exact pattern that I follow depends on how often I'm able to make cheese, how much time I have when making it, and the whim of the moment.
The point is always to have some cheese "in the pipeline" that is coming of age and ready to eat; meanwhile the medium and long-aging cheeses can sit back in the cave, semi-forgotten, until they emerge in glory.
My go-to short-aging cheeses are Camembert, Caerphilly, or Lancashire; my go-to medium-aging cheeses are Asiago, Emmentaler, and Double Gloucester or other cheddar; and my go-to long-aging cheeses are the parms and long-aged Goudas. But there are various others mixed in - definitely an occasional blue (I am especially liking the smoked blue that I have experimented with, but this is best made when the weather is cold so that the cheese will stay cold while smoking); an occasional Cantal; an occasional experiment with something altogether new.
Unfortunately, my cheese making has been rather limited and sporadic lately, and as a result my rotation has been inconsistent. I've gotten a couple of medium-aging cheeses in the cave, but really need to get a couple more long-aging cheeses (especially a parm) into the pipeline so that they can start building up age. But the last few times I've been able to make cheese, I've needed to replenish my supply of short-aging cheese, so I've made camemberts instead. Very annoying when my job gets in the way of my hobbies! Fortunately, there is some down-time coming up, so hopefully I'll be able to do some restocking of the pipeline.